Friday, March 28, 2014

Memento



Memento is a mind bending thriller from director Christopher Nolan, based off the short story Memento Mori by his brother Jonathan Nolan. It follows a man who has lost the ability to create new memories while he is on the quest to avenge his wife's death.

This is one of those films that can be used in the argument that sometimes the movie is better than the original story. The original shot story by Jonathan Nolan was good, but didn't seem to give enough context as one would like. However, the feature film expands on this idea Jonathan had and creates something better in the sense of more context. The visual aspects of the film help a lot as well, giving us a more clear cut difference between the scenes that are happening and the black and white scenes.






The idea to do the story backwards is an original one, and it's hard to imagine it working any other way. If you look at the film chronologically from the story standpoint, you would know far to much too soon. Somehow working from the conclusion to the actual beginning of the story brings along more twists and turns than would have been. Christopher Nolan does a great job with this, and delivers a great mystery as per usual. He somehow tows the line between over-the-top mystery and something that would induce an eye roll with his stories(i.e. M. Night Shyamalan, Grant Morrison) to make a great puzzle story that leaves everyone talking long after the credits roll.



I think it's important to note that aspect, we are all left discussing it. With stories like this, we aren't meant to necessarily have a clear cut answer to every question raised. The creator wants us to talk about it, and each have our own interpretation of what may have happened. Yes, there is a clear cut ending for the most part, with facts laid out by the movie at the end. However, it seems we are almost like Leonard himself, writing down what we know to be a fact and leaving the other points to either forget or change to our own liking. This approach is the backbone of any great puzzle story, and is in the likes of narratives such as the television show LOST and video game Bioshock Infinite. All these answer main questions, but leave a set to the viewers imagination. It's something that seems to be a preferred method, considering how much hate someone like M. Night Shyamalan receives for giving an almost clear cut twist and answer to the entire story that can easily be described in a sentence or two. I would challenge anyone to describe the ending to this film in the amount of effort it takes to say "Bruce Willis is dead", "the old lady is the Devil", or "the aliens weakness is water".



In the end, I think it's good we are discussing it, because that's what the artist wants us to do. We aren't meant to have the answers to everything laid out to us, we are supposed to form our own ideas from the information given. This is the characteristic of a piece of work that will live on for years and years to come, as we see it already has. Everyone who hasn't seen this movie is more likely to recommend it to a friend, just so they can talk to them about it.


8 comments:

  1. I love your point about how maybe we aren't meant to have the answers to everything laid out to us, and that we are supposed to form our own ideas from the information given. I know a lot of people who are frustrated when a film lacks resolution--myself included--but I also love it, in certain cases. I like to think that a story really has no set end or beginning, that there are endless interpretations and directions and meanings that can be gleaned from it, and I'm so happy to see filmmakers like Christopher Nolan who really embrace that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think another interesting aspect to a film like this, where you aren't given a definite resolution, is that it still has value when you rewatch it. There were people in the class, who had seen it before, and still picked up on new things. It was my third time seeing the film, and my interpretation of the ending changed completely... again.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have no doubt that we are not supposed to have all the answers after watching the film. Nolan is a brilliant filmmaker, certainly capable of supplying them if that were his intention. The missing pieces are surely by design. In fact, I'm sure a good bit of attention was given to making sure there were no clear answers to certain aspects of the story. And, it works well. I am also in agreement with your assessment of the film being better than the short story--by a long shot. Perhaps a novel would have been more competition, but probably still could not have matched the film's achievement. Also, I would not accept your challenge to sum up the film in the same one line fashion that other puzzle films can be. I don't think it can be done.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I never thought about us as Leonard, but it's so true. We choose what we want to believe (writing down facts, but changing what we want). Very interesting!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I love your discussion of the idea that what Nolan really wants is for us to talk about his film, because isn't that the point of all art? Art is meant for the recipient to interpret, regardless of the artist intentions with a piece. It means something different to each person who views it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This movie is incredibly well done. That being said, I don't agree 100% with your critique of M. Night; yes, he gives clear cut answers. But that doesn't always detract from the quality of the movie. I still love to watch Unbreakable, Signs, and The Sixth Sense over and over again. That being said, I still say that Memento is better.

    ReplyDelete
  7. You are right, the movie lends itself to interpretation and discussion, great puzzle movies will do. I think Leonard is the everyman or everywoman. Leonard is in constant pursuit of the truth. We are in constant purist of knowledge and answers. Leonard's struggle is our struggle.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree that the visual of the movie helps more with an understanding of what is going on. This is a puzzle movie and I am missing some pieces because I am still confused. But I also agree taking the movie in a backwards approach helped me full in a few of the pieces and it also made the movie more interesting.

    ReplyDelete